Neighbourgood’s Revival of a Landmark: Why Sutter Mansion Matters Today
T.F. Payne House photo circa 1887
Some buildings age.
Others endure.
And then there’s Neighbourgood Sutter Mansion: still standing, still watching, still full of life to give.
Located at 1409 Sutter Street, this Victorian beauty has seen San Francisco shift and shape itself over nearly a century and a half. But its story is far from over. In fact, it’s just getting started.
This is the revival of a landmark. A reactivation of something rare.
And it’s exactly the kind of space Neighbourgood was made for.
A Little Backstory (Because It’s a Good One)
Sutter Mansion was built in 1881, commissioned by Theodore F. Payne and his wife Mary Pauline O’Brien whose family ties run deep in California’s Gold Rush and Comstock Lode boom. Her uncle, William S. O’Brien, was one of the original Silver Kings and their fortune helped build this grand home at the height of San Francisco’s Victorian expansion.
The architect, William Curlett, gave the mansion its signature Queen Anne style with elegant Eastlake and Stick influences. It wasn’t just pretty, either; it was ahead of its time, with central heating, integrated plumbing, and even machine-made hardware, which was cutting-edge in the 1880s.
And here’s what makes it extra special: It survived the 1906 earthquake and fire. Most homes like it didn’t.
After the Payne family moved to Menlo Park post-quake, the mansion changed hands becoming everything from a YMCA, to a restaurant, to an antiques store, and later, in 2018, a boutique hotel known as Mansion on Sutter.
But even with all those transitions, the building always felt a little in-between waiting for its next chapter.
Now, it has one.
What Neighbourgood Sutter Mansion Offers Today
Neighbourgood Sutter Mansion is now a vibrant boutique hotel with 12 thoughtfully designed rooms that blend historic charm with modern comfort. Whether you’re here for a night or a few, you’ll find a welcoming space to rest and recharge.
A complimentary breakfast is available on-site, providing a perfect start to your day exploring the cit.. For those who like to keep active, our gym and fitness centre offer everything you need to stay moving.
Artworks throughout the mansion bring creativity and inspiration to every corner, adding to the unique character of the space.
Looking to host a gathering or attend an event? Our event space is ready for intimate experiences that connect people in meaningful ways.
Behind it all is a team of welcoming staff who are passionate about making your stay memorable and your experience seamless.
Neighbourgood Sutter Mansion is officially open - and you're invited.
Whether you're staying for a few nights, stopping by for an event or just curious what it feels like inside a 140-year-old mansion with new energy we’d love to see you here.
The doors are open. The vibes are good.
Come be part of what’s next.